Alloy scattering and resistivity change — adding a small percentage of Cu to Ni Copper has lower resistivity than nickel. When a small percentage of Cu is alloyed into Ni, how does the resistivity of the resulting Ni–Cu alloy change and why?
-
AIt increases due to impurity (defect) scattering of electrons
-
BIt decreases because copper is a better conductor
-
CIt may increase or decrease with no systematic trend
-
DIt remains the same for small additions
-
EIt becomes zero (superconducting) at room temperature
Answer
Correct Answer: It increases due to impurity (defect) scattering of electrons
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Electrical resistivity in metals is governed by scattering of conduction electrons from phonons, impurities, and lattice defects. Alloying even small amounts of a second element modifies scattering and therefore resistivity. Understanding this is central to materials engineering and the design of resistive alloys.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Base metal: nickel; solute: copper (small percentage).
- Crystal lattice remains metallic and substitutional.
- No phase transformation is assumed for dilute additions.
Concept / Approach:Matthiessen’s rule states ρ(T) ≈ ρ_residual + ρ_phonon(T). Impurity atoms (Cu in Ni) create local potential variations and strain fields that scatter electrons, increasing ρ_residual. Even though pure Cu has lower resistivity than pure Ni, adding Cu to Ni breaks lattice periodicity and increases total resistivity of the alloy compared with pure Ni.
Step-by-Step Solution:Introduce impurity → new scattering centers.Residual resistivity rises even at low temperature (phonon contribution minimal).Total resistivity therefore increases across the temperature range relative to pure Ni.
Verification / Alternative check:Empirical ρ–composition curves for Ni–Cu alloys show monotonic increases in ρ with solute content in the dilute regime, consistent with alloy scattering theories.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- Decrease: contradicts alloy-scattering physics.
- No trend or no change: inconsistent with well-established data.
- Zero resistivity at room temperature: impossible for ordinary alloys; superconductivity requires cryogenic conditions and specific compounds.
Common Pitfalls:
- Equating base-metal conductivity with alloy behavior; disorder dominates.
- Ignoring that impurity scattering is temperature-independent and persists at low T.
Final Answer:It increases due to impurity (defect) scattering of electrons