Statement: He emphasized the need to replace the present training program with other methods that will bring out the real merit of the managers. Conclusions: I. It is important to bring out the real merit of the managers. II. The present training program does not bring out the real merit of the managers.

Verbal Reasoning Statement and Conclusion Difficulty: Easy
Choose an option
  • A
    If only Conclusion I follows
  • B
    If only Conclusion II follows
  • C
    If either I or II follows
  • D
    If both I and II follow
  • E
    If neither I nor II follows

Answer

Correct Answer: If both I and II follow

Explanation

Introduction / Context:The speaker calls for replacing the current training with methods that “will bring out the real merit of the managers.” This is both a value statement (merit is important) and a diagnostic critique (the present program fails to do this sufficiently), yielding two testable conclusions.

Given Data / Assumptions:

  • A need exists to replace the current training program.
  • The stated purpose of replacement: bring out real merit.
  • Implied judgment that current training falls short on this objective.

Concept / Approach:Conclusion I is the explicit objective; if the speaker centers replacement on revealing merit, importance is implied. Conclusion II follows because replacement is advocated precisely due to the present program’s inadequacy in bringing out that merit; otherwise replacement on that ground would not be necessary.

Step-by-Step Solution:1) The goal “bring out real merit” → I follows.2) If the present program already brought out real merit, no replacement for that reason would be needed → II follows.

Verification / Alternative check:Suppose the present program were excellent at revealing merit; then the motivation to replace for that very reason would not exist. Therefore, II is logically embedded in the recommendation.

Why Other Options Are Wrong:Accepting only I or only II ignores the mutual reinforcement present in the statement; “neither” contradicts the explicit text.

Common Pitfalls:Missing the implicit critique in a recommendation phrased around a specific deficiency.

Final Answer:If both I and II follow.

Discussion & Comments
No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion