Statement: He emphasized the need to replace the present training program with other methods that will bring out the real merit of the managers. Conclusions: I. It is important to bring out the real merit of the managers. II. The present training program does not bring out the real merit of the managers.
-
AIf only Conclusion I follows
-
BIf only Conclusion II follows
-
CIf either I or II follows
-
DIf both I and II follow
-
EIf neither I nor II follows
Answer
Correct Answer: If both I and II follow
Explanation
Introduction / Context:The speaker calls for replacing the current training with methods that “will bring out the real merit of the managers.” This is both a value statement (merit is important) and a diagnostic critique (the present program fails to do this sufficiently), yielding two testable conclusions.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- A need exists to replace the current training program.
- The stated purpose of replacement: bring out real merit.
- Implied judgment that current training falls short on this objective.
Concept / Approach:Conclusion I is the explicit objective; if the speaker centers replacement on revealing merit, importance is implied. Conclusion II follows because replacement is advocated precisely due to the present program’s inadequacy in bringing out that merit; otherwise replacement on that ground would not be necessary.
Step-by-Step Solution:1) The goal “bring out real merit” → I follows.2) If the present program already brought out real merit, no replacement for that reason would be needed → II follows.
Verification / Alternative check:Suppose the present program were excellent at revealing merit; then the motivation to replace for that very reason would not exist. Therefore, II is logically embedded in the recommendation.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:Accepting only I or only II ignores the mutual reinforcement present in the statement; “neither” contradicts the explicit text.
Common Pitfalls:Missing the implicit critique in a recommendation phrased around a specific deficiency.
Final Answer:If both I and II follow.