Rearrange the parts of the sentence in the correct order: Amartya Sen lays claim P - to a history of writing Q - some of the finest research papers R - that have been published.

Difficulty: Medium

Correct Answer: PQR

Explanation:


Introduction / Context:
Sentence rearrangement questions check a learner's ability to understand sentence structure, logical flow, and correct order of clauses or phrases. In exams, such questions are presented in the form of parts labelled P, Q, and R which must be arranged to produce a meaningful and grammatically correct sentence. Here the subject is Amartya Sen, a well known economist, and the sentence talks about his claim to a history of research writing.


Given Data / Assumptions:
The fixed opening is Amartya Sen lays claim. The jumbled segments are P - to a history of writing, Q - some of the finest research papers, and R - that have been published. We must place these segments so that the sentence reads naturally and expresses a complete idea. We assume normal modern English usage in which lays claim is followed by a suitable prepositional phrase and then by the thing claimed.


Concept / Approach:
The expression lays claim is commonly followed by the preposition to, and then by the object of the claim. Therefore the first segment after the fixed opening should begin with to. This points strongly towards P. Once that is placed, we must see what Amartya Sen is claiming. He is claiming a history of writing something, which is further explained by Q and R. Q presents the object some of the finest research papers, and R adds a relative clause that have been published. The natural order is to introduce the general category first and then add the relative clause that have been published, which describes the papers.


Step-by-Step Solution:
Step 1: Start with the fixed part: Amartya Sen lays claim.
Step 2: Identify that lays claim must be followed by the preposition to, so choose P: to a history of writing.
Step 3: Ask what kind of history of writing is being described. The phrase some of the finest research papers fits as the object of writing, so place Q next.
Step 4: Finally, attach the relative clause that have been published as R to describe these research papers.
Step 5: The complete sentence becomes: Amartya Sen lays claim to a history of writing some of the finest research papers that have been published.


Verification / Alternative check:
If we try any other order, the sentence either becomes ungrammatical or illogical. For example, starting with Q after lays claim gives lays claim some of the finest research papers, which lacks a preposition and sounds incorrect. Placing R immediately after lays claim would produce lays claim that have been published, which also fails to connect properly. Only the order PQR produces a smooth, meaningful sentence with correct preposition usage and logical descriptive flow.


Why Other Options Are Wrong:
Option A, QRP, starts with some of the finest research papers after lays claim, ignoring the required preposition to. Option C, RQP, begins the description with a relative clause that has no clear noun to refer to. Option D, QPR, splits the object from its descriptive clause in an unnatural way. Option E, PRQ, places that have been published immediately after to a history of writing, which breaks the connection between writing and some of the finest research papers. None of these alternatives yields a correct, fluent sentence.


Common Pitfalls:
Students may overlook the importance of prepositions that follow fixed expressions like lay claim to, agree with, or depend on. Others may try to arrange segments only by meaning and forget that relative clauses like that have been published must come after the noun they describe. A systematic approach is to find connectors such as prepositions and relative pronouns, then match them to the words they logically govern. Practising this technique makes sentence rearrangement questions far easier to handle.


Final Answer:
The correct order of parts is PQR, giving the sentence: Amartya Sen lays claim to a history of writing some of the finest research papers that have been published.

More Questions from English

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion