Origins of plant clones: Plants derived sexually from the same parent plant are ____ , while plants regenerated from somatic (non-gametic) tissues of the same plant are ____.
-
Aidentical, different
-
Bdifferent, also different
-
Cdifferent, identical
-
Dplants cannot be derived from somatic tissue
-
Eidentical, identical regardless of method
Answer
Correct Answer: different, identical
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Genetic variation arises through sexual reproduction because gametes are formed via meiosis and undergo random fusion. In contrast, regeneration from somatic tissues (micropropagation, organogenesis, or somatic embryogenesis) is a clonal, asexual process that preserves the donor genotype.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Sexual progeny inherit recombined chromosomes from meiosis and independent assortment.
- Somatic tissue culture uses mitotic cells without meiosis, maintaining genotype.
- Somaclonal variation can occur but is generally an exception, not the rule.
Concept / Approach:Sexual reproduction produces genetically different offspring (except in rare apomixis or selfing scenarios with limited variation). Asexual regeneration yields genetically identical plants—clones of the source plant—assuming no culture-induced mutations.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Recognize that meiosis and fertilization introduce genetic recombination.Conclude that sexually derived siblings differ from each other and from the parent.Recognize that somatic regeneration is clonal → identical to donor.Verification / Alternative check:Horticulture relies on clonal propagation (cuttings, micropropagation) to preserve elite cultivars, confirming that somatic derivatives match the donor genotype and phenotype.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
Identical, different: reverses the true relationship.Different, also different: ignores clonal nature of somatic regeneration.Somatic plants cannot be derived: false; tissue culture routinely does this.Identical, identical regardless of method: sexual reproduction is not clonal.Common Pitfalls:Overlooking somaclonal variation as a rare complication; assuming sexual selfing always yields identical progeny (it does not due to segregation).
Final Answer:different, identical.