Water–cement ratio and workability: Identify the INCORRECT statement regarding concrete strength and handling
-
AA rich mix generally develops higher strength than a lean mix of the same workability obtained by adding excessive water
-
BConcrete strength decreases as the water–cement ratio increases, all else equal
-
CIf the water–cement ratio is less than 0.45, the concrete is not workable and will produce honeycombing
-
DProper compaction by mechanical vibration increases the strength of concrete
-
ENone of these
Answer
Correct Answer: If the water–cement ratio is less than 0.45, the concrete is not workable and will produce honeycombing
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Workability, water–cement ratio (w/c), and compaction quality jointly control concrete strength and durability. Misconceptions about “minimum w/c for workability” often lead to adding unnecessary water, compromising performance.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Standard concrete constituents, conventional aggregates.
- Workability may be improved by admixtures and grading, not only by water.
- Mechanical vibration is available for compaction.
Concept / Approach:(a) and (b) reflect the classic w/c–strength relationship: more water (for the same cement) reduces paste strength and increases porosity. (d) is true: better compaction reduces voids and raises strength. Statement (c) is incorrect as an absolute rule: low w/c mixes can be workable using plasticizers, optimized grading, and proper vibration; they do not inevitably cause honeycombing if placed correctly.
Step-by-Step Solution:Assess (a): rich vs lean with excess water → rich mix stronger → correct.Assess (b): strength decreases with increasing w/c → correct.Assess (c): blanket claim that w/c < 0.45 is unworkable is false; admixtures and vibration enable placement → incorrect statement.Assess (d): mechanical vibration improves density → correct.
Verification / Alternative check:Modern mixes frequently target w/c below 0.45 (even 0.30–0.40) with superplasticizers to achieve both workability and high strength.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:Option (e) says none are incorrect, but (c) demonstrably is incorrect.
Common Pitfalls:Adding water to “improve workability” instead of using admixtures; under-vibration leading to trapped air despite adequate slump.
Final Answer:If the water–cement ratio is less than 0.45, the concrete is not workable and will produce honeycombing is the incorrect statement.