Effective span rules for beams and slabs — identify the correct statement(s) (Use IS code practice; consider clear span, effective depth, and centre-to-centre of supports.)
-
AFor a simply supported beam: effective span = lesser of (clear span + effective depth) and centre-to-centre distance of supports.
-
BFor a simply supported slab: effective span = lesser of (clear span + effective depth) and centre-to-centre distance of supports.
-
CFor a continuous beam or slab: effective span may be taken as the lesser of (clear span + effective depth) and centre-to-centre of supports, provided the support width is small compared to the span.
-
DFor spans carried on roller or rocker bearings: effective span = distance between the centres of the bearings.
-
EAll of the above.
Answer
Correct Answer: All of the above.
Explanation
Introduction:In reinforced concrete design, the effective span determines bending moments and deflections. Codes specify how to measure spans depending on support conditions and continuity. This question checks familiarity with code-consistent definitions used in beams and slabs.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Simply supported versus continuous members.
- Slabs and beams follow the same span logic for many cases.
- Roller/rocker bearings are special supports with defined bearing centres.
- Support width is assumed small relative to span.
Concept / Approach:The effective span is the controlling dimension for analysis. Codes permit taking the lesser of two measures to avoid overestimating span: (clear span + effective depth) or the centre-to-centre of supports. This reflects how compression struts and tension ties develop within the member depth and through bearing widths.
Step-by-Step Solution:1) Simply supported beam: adopt min(clear span + effective depth, centre-to-centre).2) Simply supported slab: same rule applies because the slab behaves as a flexural member spanning between supports.3) Continuous beam/slab: the same minima logic applies; supports are often narrow relative to span, justifying the rule.4) Roller/rocker bearings: the span is taken between bearing centres by definition.
Verification / Alternative check:Design examples show small changes in effective span can noticeably change design moments; using the lesser value is conservative and code-aligned.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:Each statement A–D is individually correct; therefore “All of the above” is also correct and the best choice here.
Common Pitfalls:Confusing clear span with effective span; ignoring the member depth; or using face-to-face distance when code requires centre-to-centre for some supports.
Final Answer:All of the above.