PERT scheduling: if activity times are given as to (optimistic), tm (most likely), and tp (pessimistic), what is the variance of the activity duration used for network analysis?
-
A((tp - to) / 6)^2
-
B((tp - tm) / 6)^2
-
C((tm - to) / 6)^2
-
D((tp + to - 2 tm) / 6)^2
-
E(tp - to)^2
Answer
Correct Answer: ((tp - to) / 6)^2
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Program Evaluation and Review Technique (PERT) models activity duration as a beta distribution using three time estimates: optimistic (to), most likely (tm), and pessimistic (tp). PERT converts these to an expected time and a variance to analyze critical paths and project completion risk.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Activity time estimates: to, tm, tp.
- Standard PERT (original) parameters are used.
- Independence between activities is assumed for variance summation along paths.
Concept / Approach:PERT expected duration te = (to + 4 tm + tp) / 6. The variance is derived from the assumed beta distribution shape using the range (tp − to). The canonical PERT variance expression is Var = ((tp − to) / 6)^2, which reflects greater uncertainty when the pessimistic-optimistic spread is large.
Step-by-Step Solution:Recall PERT mean: te = (to + 4 tm + tp) / 6.Recall PERT variance: σ^2 = ((tp − to) / 6)^2.Identify the provided choices and select the canonical formula.
Verification / Alternative check:Numerical checks: if tp − to is zero (no uncertainty), variance becomes zero, which is logical. Larger spreads proportionally increase variance.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- Using (tp − tm) or (tm − to) ignores the full range of uncertainty.
- ((tp + to − 2 tm) / 6)^2 is not a standard PERT variance.
- (tp − to)^2 omits the 1/36 scaling and overstates variance by 36×.
Common Pitfalls:Confusing the mean formula with the variance; forgetting the division by 6 before squaring.
Final Answer:((tp - to) / 6)^2