In this English grammar question, a sentence is given in active voice in the form of a question. Select the option that best expresses the same idea in passive voice. Sentence: "Have you created this beautiful artwork?"

Difficulty: Easy

Correct Answer: Has this beautiful artwork been created by you?

Explanation:


Introduction / Context:

This question involves changing a present perfect yes or no question from active voice into passive voice. The speaker is asking whether the listener is the creator of a piece of artwork. The correct option must keep the question form, the present perfect tense, and the same meaning, while putting the artwork in the subject position.


Given Data / Assumptions:

- Original sentence: "Have you created this beautiful artwork?"

- Subject in the active sentence: "you".

- Object: "this beautiful artwork".

- The tense is present perfect expressed through "have created".

- We must form a passive question in present perfect where the artwork becomes the subject and the agent remains "you".


Concept / Approach:

For present perfect questions in passive voice, the auxiliary "have" or "has" comes first, followed by the subject, then "been" plus the past participle. In this case, the new subject is "this beautiful artwork". Since "artwork" is singular, we use "has" instead of "have". The past participle of "create" is "created". The agent phrase "by you" can be placed at the end of the sentence. The word order must still follow the pattern of a yes or no question.


Step-by-Step Solution:
Step 1: Identify the elements of the active question. Subject: you. Verb phrase: have created. Object: this beautiful artwork. Step 2: Move "this beautiful artwork" to the subject position. Step 3: Change the auxiliary to "has" because the new subject is singular. Step 4: Form the passive question "Has this beautiful artwork been created" and add "by you" at the end. Step 5: Check that the whole sentence sounds natural and that it remains a yes or no question in present perfect passive.


Verification / Alternative check:

The question "Has this beautiful artwork been created by you?" accurately keeps the time reference, the meaning, and the interrogative form of the original. It correctly uses "has" with a singular subject, includes "been created" as the passive verb phrase, and clearly asks whether the listener is the artist. It is a standard and natural English passive question.


Why Other Options Are Wrong:

Some options use present simple instead of present perfect, which changes the time frame and removes the sense that the action may have a result in the present. Others misuse continuous forms like "was being created", which refer to an action in progress in the past and do not suit the context. There are also sentences with unnatural noun phrases such as "creating is done by you", which do not sound like real questions. One option incorrectly uses "had" rather than "has" and changes the tense to past perfect.


Common Pitfalls:

Students often forget to match the auxiliary verb to the new subject when they move from active to passive voice. Another common mistake is to keep the original word order of the active question and add "by" phrases, which does not create a real passive structure. When working with questions, many learners also forget to keep the auxiliary at the beginning of the sentence. Following the pattern auxiliary plus subject plus "been" plus past participle helps maintain correct grammar.


Final Answer:

The correct passive voice question is "Has this beautiful artwork been created by you?"

More Questions from English

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion