P, Q and R are three typists who working simultaneously can type 216 pages in 4 hours. In one hour, R can type as many pages more than Q as Q can type more than P. During a period of five hours, R can type as many pages as P can during seven hours. How many pages does each of them type per hour ?
Aptitude
Time and Work
Difficulty: Medium
Choose an option
-
A14, 17, 20
-
B15, 17, 22
-
C15, 18, 21
-
D16, 18, 22
Answer
Correct Answer: 15, 18, 21
Explanation
### Concept & Linear Equations
Translate the descriptive relationships between their work rates into a system of linear equations.
### Step-by-Step Solution
* **Establish Hourly Rates:**
Let the number of pages typed per hour by P, Q, and R be $P$, $Q$, and $R$ respectively.
* **Equation 1 (Combined Rate):**
Together, they type $216$ pages in $4$ hours.
Combined hourly rate: $P + Q + R = \frac{216}{4} = 54$.
* **Equation 2 (Rate Differences):**
"R can type as many pages more than Q as Q can type more than P."
$R - Q = Q - P$
Rearranging gives: $P + R = 2Q$.
* **Solve for Q:**
Substitute $(P + R)$ with $2Q$ in Equation 1:
$(P + R) + Q = 54$
$2Q + Q = 54$
$3Q = 54$
$Q = 18$ pages/hour.
* **Equation 3 (Time/Work Equivalency):**
"In 5 hours, R types as many pages as P does in 7 hours."
$5R = 7P$
$R = \frac{7}{5}P$.
* **Solve for P and R:**
We know $P + R = 2Q$, and $Q = 18$, so $P + R = 36$.
Substitute $R = \frac{7}{5}P$:
$P + \frac{7}{5}P = 36$
$\frac{12P}{5} = 36$
$P = \frac{36 \times 5}{12} = 3 \times 5 = 15$ pages/hour.
Now, calculate $R$:
$R = \frac{7}{5} \times 15 = 7 \times 3 = 21$ pages/hour.
The rates are P = $15$, Q = $18$, R = $21$.
### Exam Strategy & Shortcut
Use Option Elimination based on the first extracted rule: $R - Q = Q - P$. This implies the rates must be in an arithmetic progression.
Check differences in options:
(a) $14, 17, 20$ (diff is 3, valid)
(b) $15, 17, 22$ (diffs are 2 and 5, invalid)
(c) $15, 18, 21$ (diff is 3, valid)
(d) $16, 18, 22$ (diffs are 2 and 4, invalid)
Now check the "5 hrs of R = 7 hrs of P" rule ($5 \times R = 7 \times P$) on the remaining valid options:
Test (a): $5 \times 20 = 100$; $7 \times 14 = 98$ (Not equal).
Test (c): $5 \times 21 = 105$; $7 \times 15 = 105$ (Equal!).
### Common Pitfall
Setting up the relative rate equation incorrectly. Interpreting "R types as many more than Q" as $R + Q$ instead of $R - Q$ will completely break the algebraic flow.
### Final Answer
Therefore, the correct answer is **15, 18, 21**.