Stability of masonry dam (sliding check): The force of friction at the base should be at least what multiple of the total horizontal water pressure per metre length to avoid sliding?

Mechanical Engineering Strength of Materials Difficulty: Medium
Choose an option
  • A
    equal to the total water pressure
  • B
    1.5 times the total water pressure
  • C
    double the total water pressure
  • D
    2.5 times the total water pressure
  • E
    0.5 times the total water pressure

Answer

Correct Answer: 1.5 times the total water pressure

Explanation

Introduction / Context:For gravity and masonry dams, sliding stability is ensured by providing adequate frictional resistance at the dam–foundation interface against the horizontal water thrust. Design is often done with a prescribed factor of safety against sliding to account for uncertainties in loads, material properties, and uplift forces.

Given Data / Assumptions:

  • Total horizontal water pressure per metre length is P_w.
  • Resultant resisting friction is μ * W, where W is effective vertical force (including self-weight and considering uplift, if any).
  • A standard factor of safety against sliding is adopted in preliminary design.

Concept / Approach:The no-sliding condition requires μ * W ≥ P_w. For design safety, codes and classic practice adopt a factor of safety F_s, so μ * W ≥ F_s * P_w. A commonly used minimum F_s is about 1.5 for normal loading conditions, implying frictional resistance at least 1.5 times the driving water thrust.

Step-by-Step Solution:

Define F_s = (available friction) / (driving thrust) = (μ * W) / P_w.Adopt F_s ≥ 1.5 for normal load combinations.Therefore, μ * W ≥ 1.5 * P_w → friction at least 1.5 times water pressure.

Verification / Alternative check:Some practices may adopt larger factors for unusual loads (e.g., earthquake, flood). For the baseline question with typical options, 1.5 is the accepted minimum.

Why Other Options Are Wrong:

  • Equal to P_w gives F_s = 1.0 (no safety margin).
  • Double or 2.5 times are conservative beyond the common minimum; not typically specified as the minimum.
  • 0.5 times is unsafe (F_s < 1).

Common Pitfalls:Ignoring uplift or sediment pressure; confusing overturning checks with sliding; using peak instead of long-term friction coefficients without safety factors.

Final Answer:1.5 times the total water pressure

Discussion & Comments
No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion