More Questions from Data Sufficiency

Question below is followed by three statements I, II and III. You have to determine whether the data given in the statement is sufficient for answering the question. $y$ litres mixture of milk and water contains milk and water in the ratio $a : b$ respectively. The milkman sold $z$ litres of the mixture and added 10 litres of pure milk and 8 litres of water to the remaining mixture such that the ratio of milk and water in the final mixture became $5 : 4$ respectively. Find the respective ratio of amount of milk in the initial mixture and amount of milk in the final mixture. Statement I: A 54 litres mixture of syrup and water contains syrup and water in the ratio $a : b$ respectively. If 10 litres of syrup and 6 litres of water is added to the mixture, the ratio of syrup and water becomes $4 : 3$ respectively. Statement II: A 60 litres mixture of milk and water contains milk and water in the ratio $7 : 5$ respectively. If $z$ litres of the mixture is replaced with water, the ratio of milk and water in the mixture becomes $7 : 23$ respectively. Statement III: $y = 3z$

Verbal Reasoning Data Sufficiency Difficulty: Hard
Choose an option
  • A
    Only I and II together
  • B
    Either I or II and III together
  • C
    Any two of the three
  • D
    All I, II and III together
  • E
    Cannot be answered even after combining all the three statements

Answer

Correct Answer: All I, II and III together

Explanation

### Concept & Mixtures Data Sufficiency To find the initial to final milk ratio, we need the initial quantity of milk and the final quantity of milk. Initial Milk = $y \times \frac{a}{a+b}$. Final Milk = $(y - z) \times \frac{a}{a+b} + 10$. We need to determine the variables $a, b, y,$ and $z$. ### Step-by-Step Solution * **Evaluate Statement I:** 54L mixture in ratio $a:b$. Adding 10L syrup and 6L water gives $4:3$. Let initial syrup be $S$ and water be $W$. $S+W = 54$. $$ \frac{S + 10}{W + 6} = \frac{4}{3} \implies \frac{S + 10}{54 - S + 6} = \frac{4}{3} $$ $$ 3S + 30 = 240 - 4S \implies 7S = 210 \implies S = 30 $$ So, $W = 24$. The ratio $a:b = 30:24 = 5:4$. Statement I gives us $a$ and $b$, but not $y$ or $z$. * **Evaluate Statement II:** 60L mixture in $7:5$ ratio ($35L$ milk, $25L$ water). Replaced $z$ litres with water, new ratio is $7:23$. Milk left = $35 - \frac{7}{12}z$. Water = $25 - \frac{5}{12}z + z = 25 + \frac{7}{12}z$. $$ \frac{35 - \frac{7}{12}z}{25 + \frac{7}{12}z} = \frac{7}{23} $$ $23(35 - \frac{7}{12}z) = 7(25 + \frac{7}{12}z)$. Solving this yields $z = 36$. Statement II gives us $z$, but not $a, b,$ or $y$. * **Evaluate Statement III:** $y = 3z$. This only gives a relationship between $y$ and $z$. * **Combining Information:** Combining I, II, and III gives $a:b = 5:4$, $z = 36$, and $y = 3 \times 36 = 108$. With all variables known, we can find the exact required ratio. ### Exam Strategy & Shortcut Instead of fully solving Statements I and II, recognize what variables they allow you to isolate. Stmt I has only 1 unknown proportion set ($S$ out of 54), so it yields $a:b$. Stmt II has 1 unknown ($z$), so it yields $z$. Stmt III connects $y$ to $z$. To solve the main equation, all components are necessary. ### Common Pitfall Assuming that providing absolute values for a different liquid (syrup) in Statement I makes it invalid. The ratio $a:b$ is an independent constant linking the scenarios. ### Final Answer Therefore, the correct answer is **All I, II and III together**.
Discussion & Comments
No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion