Critical Reasoning — Assumptions Statement: “Deepak has a large collection of books and keeps purchasing new books to add to his collection.” Which assumptions are implicit?

Introduction / Context:
The statement describes Deepak’s repeated behavior regarding books. We must infer the minimal beliefs that make this description reasonable.

Given Data / Assumptions:

• I: Deepak loves and cares for books.
• II: Deepak has read each and every book that he has purchased.

Concept / Approach:
From continued acquisition and a substantial collection, it is reasonable to assume positive attitude or love for books (I). Reading every single book (II) is an unnecessary and extreme assumption.

Step-by-Step Solution:
1) Persistent purchasing for a collection indicates interest, appreciation, or love—assumption I.2) Collections often contain unread items; the behavior does not guarantee complete readership. Hence II is not necessary.3) Negate I: If Deepak does not like books, the repeated purchases and collection become odd and unmotivated.4) Negate II: Even if he has not read every book, the statement remains fully sensible.

Verification / Alternative check:
Collectors (stamps, art, vinyl) often acquire items for curation, not exhaustive use. The same logic applies to books.

Why Other Options Are Wrong:

• Only II / Both / Either: II is not required and overreaches.
• Neither: I is indeed implicit in the behavior described.

Common Pitfalls:
Avoid equating purchase with consumption. Acquisition signals preference; completion is an extra claim.

Final Answer:
Only assumption I is implicit