Difficulty: Medium
Correct Answer: Only argument II is strong
Explanation:
Given data
Concept/Approach (weighing outcome relevance)
A strong argument should connect directly to the purpose of education. Depth and expertise are core objectives of post-graduate study; mere earlier employment is a narrow, short-term gain.
Step 1: Assess Argument I
Earlier employment is not a sufficient reason to eliminate advanced education across disciplines; it ignores societal needs for specialists and research.
Step 2: Assess Argument II
Directly addresses the core function—advanced depth—which would indeed be harmed by scrapping the system. Hence strong.
Final Answer
Only argument II is strong.
Discussion & Comments