Statement: “Like a mad man, I decided to follow him.” Assumptions I & II: I. I am not actually a mad man (the phrase is a comparison/simile). II. I am a mad man. Choose the option that correctly identifies the implicit assumption(s).
-
AOnly assumption I is implicit.
-
BEither assumption I or II is implicit.
-
COnly assumption II is implicit.
-
DNeither assumption I nor II is implicit.
-
EBoth assumptions I and II are implicit.
Answer
Correct Answer: Only assumption I is implicit.
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Idiomatic expressions such as “like a mad man” typically signal manner, not literal identity. We must determine which belief the statement relies on to convey meaning.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- I. The speaker is using a simile—he behaved as if mad, but is not actually mad.
- II. The speaker is literally a mad man.
Concept / Approach:In English usage, “like a …” constructs normally compare behavior to a stereotype. The sentence’s intelligibility depends on non-literal, comparative reading rather than identity assertion.
Step-by-Step Solution:1) “Like a mad man” modifies the manner of following (recklessly, impulsively).2) For that to be meaningful, we assume the speaker is not literally mad (I); otherwise the comparison collapses.3) II contradicts I and is not required.
Verification / Alternative check:If the speaker were literally mad, the phrase would be tautological or odd (“like myself”). The idiom’s force comes from the comparison, not identity.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:Only II: contradicts idiomatic sense. Either/Both: cannot both hold. Neither: ignores the comparative reading required.
Common Pitfalls:Taking idioms literally; overlooking the grammatical role of “like.”
Final Answer:Only assumption I is implicit.