Statement: “A society is in danger when those who have never learned to obey are given the right to command.” Assumptions I & II: I. A good commander should be disciplined (has learned to obey). II. The speaker has witnessed societal vices being controlled by undisciplined leaders. Choose the option that correctly identifies the implicit assumption(s).
-
AOnly assumption I is implicit.
-
BOnly assumption II is implicit.
-
CEither I or II is implicit.
-
DNeither I nor II is implicit.
-
EBoth I and II are implicit.
Answer
Correct Answer: Only assumption I is implicit.
Explanation
Introduction / Context:The aphorism links fitness to command with prior discipline. It warns of danger when command is handed to those lacking the formative experience of obedience.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- I. Effective command presupposes discipline—learning to obey before leading.
- II. The speaker has specifically observed undisciplined leaders handling societal vices.
Concept / Approach:The general warning requires only a normative premise about leadership qualities (I). It does not require autobiographical evidence or specific experiences (II).
Step-by-Step Solution:1) “Danger when non-obedient command” implies: good command derives from discipline and obedience training (I).2) The statement is a principle, not a report of witnessed events; II is unnecessary.
Verification / Alternative check:The maxim remains valid as advice even if the speaker has never observed such cases personally.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:Only II/Either/Both: add contingent facts not required for the normative claim. Neither: ignores the leadership-requires-discipline premise.
Common Pitfalls:Confusing normative aphorisms with empirical testimony.
Final Answer:Only assumption I is implicit.