For improving the quality factor (Q) of a radio‐frequency coil (inductor), which choice of wire geometry is best: long, thin, thick, or long and thin? Explain considering Q = ωL / R and copper loss minimization.

Difficulty: Easy

Correct Answer: thick

Explanation:


Introduction / Context:
In electrical and electronics engineering, the quality factor Q of a coil indicates how efficiently it stores magnetic energy relative to resistive losses. A higher Q means lower copper loss and sharper resonance in tuned circuits. This question asks how the choice of wire affects Q when the inductance value is fixed by design.


Given Data / Assumptions:

  • Quality factor: Q = ωL / R for a coil at angular frequency ω.
  • Inductance L is set by turns, core/geometric form, and coil dimensions.
  • Resistance R depends on wire length, cross-sectional area, temperature, and frequency (skin effect at RF).


Concept / Approach:
To increase Q at a given frequency and inductance, we must reduce the series resistance R. For a given resistivity ρ and length ℓ, R = ρℓ / A, where A is the conductor's cross-sectional area. A thicker wire increases A, which reduces R and thereby increases Q. A longer wire increases ℓ, which increases R and lowers Q. At radio frequencies, skin depth reduces the effective cross-section, further favoring thicker or Litz wire to keep R small.


Step-by-Step Solution:

Write Q = ωL / R; maximize Q by minimizing R for the chosen L.Use R = ρℓ / A; increasing A (thicker wire) decreases R.Avoid unnecessary length; longer wire increases R and lowers Q.


Verification / Alternative check:

Compare two coils with identical L: the coil wound with thicker wire exhibits lower DC and AC (skin-effect) resistance and hence higher measured Q.


Why Other Options Are Wrong:

'long' increases resistance and reduces Q.'thin' increases resistance by reducing area.'long and thin' is the worst combination for Q.'short and thick' would be ideal, but the option provided as correct among the listed choices is 'thick' (shortness is implied by good winding practice).


Common Pitfalls:

Ignoring skin effect; assuming inductance alone sets Q without considering loss.


Final Answer:

thick

More Questions from Measurements and Instrumentation

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion