Simple curve geometry for track versine: If L is the chord length of a rail on a circular curve of radius R, what is the versine (mid-ordinate) h?

Difficulty: Easy

Correct Answer: h = L^2 / (8R)

Explanation:


Introduction / Context:
Versine (sagitta) measurements are widely used in railway track geometry to quantify curvature using a chord and a mid-ordinate. This relation allows quick field checks without directly measuring radius R.


Given Data / Assumptions:

  • Circular curve of constant radius R.
  • Chord length along the rail = L.
  • Versine h is the mid-ordinate from the chord to the arc.


Concept / Approach:
From circle geometry, the exact sagitta is h = R − sqrt(R^2 − (L/2)^2). For railway practice (L small relative to R), the binomial approximation gives the standard working formula h ≈ L^2 / (8R). This is the textbook relation used for versine-based curvature checks.


Step-by-Step Solution:

Start with exact: h = R − sqrt(R^2 − (L/2)^2).Use approximation for small (L/R): sqrt(R^2 − (L/2)^2) ≈ R − (L^2 / (8R)).Therefore, h ≈ L^2 / (8R).


Verification / Alternative check:
For a sample case (e.g., L = 10 m, R = 1000 m), exact and approximate h values are nearly identical, validating the approximation for typical track work where R is large compared to L.


Why Other Options Are Wrong:

  • Forms like 2R/L^2, R^2/(8L), 8R/L are dimensionally inconsistent for length.
  • L/(2R) is linear in L; sagitta scales with L^2 for small chords.


Common Pitfalls:

  • Using the exact expression unnecessarily in routine checks, adding complexity.
  • Confusing versine with mid-chord offset for alignment deviations (a different application).


Final Answer:
h = L^2 / (8R)

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion