Achieving high accuracy in geodetic surveys: which treatment is essential? Select the statement that best supports the higher accuracy sought in geodetic (large-area) surveys.
-
AIgnore curvature of the Earth to simplify computations
-
BAccount for the Earth’s curvature in angles and distances
-
CTreat angles between geodesics as plane angles without correction
-
DNone of these
-
EUse only plane surveying formulas for all extents
Answer
Correct Answer: Account for the Earth’s curvature in angles and distances
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Geodetic surveys cover long lines and large areas where the assumption of a flat Earth becomes invalid. To attain high positional accuracy, the computations must reflect the true geometry of the Earth, including curvature and, where required, the ellipsoidal model used for a datum.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Survey spans are large enough that plane approximations introduce non-negligible error.
- Angles are observed between lines on a curved surface (geodesics).
- Standard geodetic reductions, including curvature and possibly refraction, are applied.
Concept / Approach:
High accuracy requires modelling the Earth as an ellipsoid (or sphere as a first approximation). Distances must be reduced to the ellipsoid; angles must consider the convergence of meridians and curvature. Plane surveying formulas can be used only after appropriate map projections and geodetic reductions are performed.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Identify scale: large extent → geodetic treatment necessary.Incorporate curvature corrections and, if needed, projection conversions.Choose the option that explicitly includes curvature: (b).Verification / Alternative check:
National control networks universally use ellipsoidal models and geodetic reductions—evidence that curvature must be accounted for to attain sub-arcsecond accuracies.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
Ignoring curvature or using only plane formulas leads to bias over long extents; (c) is incomplete without corrections.
Common Pitfalls:
Applying plane computations directly to geodetic observations; neglecting projection scale factors when moving to map coordinates.
Final Answer:
Account for the Earth’s curvature in angles and distances