Highway organization: Under whose direct control does the Executive Engineer (Roads) execute works in a typical PWD hierarchy?
-
ASuperintending Engineer
-
BSecretary to the Government
-
CChief Engineer
-
DNone of these
-
EDistrict Collector
Answer
Correct Answer: Superintending Engineer
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Public Works Department (PWD) organizations generally follow a hierarchical structure for planning, sanctioning, and executing highway works. Understanding reporting lines is essential for contract administration, approvals, and escalation of technical issues.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Typical PWD chain of command.
- Executive Engineer (EE) is the field officer responsible for execution.
- Superintending Engineer (SE) oversees a circle consisting of multiple divisions.
Concept / Approach:
In the standard hierarchy, the Chief Engineer provides statewide technical leadership and policy, the Superintending Engineer supervises several Executive Engineers, and each EE heads a division and executes works through Assistant Engineers and Junior Engineers. Secretaries to Government handle policy and finance, not the direct day-to-day control of execution by an EE.
Step-by-Step Reasoning:
Identify operational control level → SE supervises EEs.Confirm administrative vs. technical control → day-to-day execution lies with EE under SE.Hence, the EE executes works under direct control of the SE.Verification / Alternative check:
Standard PWD manuals and organizational charts across states reflect this chain: CE → SE → EE → AE → JE, with sanctioned powers and responsibilities defined at each level.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- Secretary to Government: policy/administrative head, not direct field control.
- Chief Engineer: heads zones/branches but does not directly supervise each division’s daily execution.
- “None of these” and “District Collector”: do not represent the direct technical control line for execution.
Common Pitfalls:
- Confusing sanctioning authority with day-to-day operational control.
Final Answer:
Superintending Engineer.