Super-elevation formula for hill road curves: If V is the design speed in km/h and R is the radius of a horizontal curve (m), what relationship correctly expresses the required super-elevation when combined with side friction?
-
Ae = V^2 / (225 R)
-
Be + f = V^2 / (225 R)
-
Ce = V^2 / (127 R)
-
De + f = V^2 / (127 R)
-
Ee = f = V / (15 R)
Answer
Correct Answer: e + f = V^2 / (225 R)
Explanation
Introduction / Context:On horizontal curves, the centripetal demand V^2/R is met by a combination of super-elevation (e) and side friction (f). For highway design in metric units with speed in km/h and radius in metres, a standard constant appears in the relationship used to size super-elevation and check comfort and safety.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- V in km/h, R in m.
- e is super-elevation (dimensionless; e = tan θ).
- f is side friction factor (dimensionless).
- Standard highway design conditions (not rail).
Concept / Approach:
The governing equilibrium is e + f = V^2/(225 R) in highway practice with the 225 constant valid for km/h and metres. Designers choose e up to an adopted maximum (often around 7–10% depending on terrain/urban constraints) and use a limiting f for comfort and safety, then solve for R or e as necessary.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Start from equilibrium of lateral acceleration: V^2/(g R) balanced by e + f in small-angle approximation.Convert units to km/h and m → constant 225 emerges.Thus, e + f = V^2 / (225 R).Verification / Alternative check:
Design charts and IRC formulae consistently employ this relationship for highway curves. Values with 127 are associated with railway practice (speed in km/h), not standard highway equations with f included.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- e = V^2/(225 R): Ignores side friction contribution.
- Expressions with 127: Not the conventional constant for highway super-elevation with friction.
- e = f = V/(15 R): Dimensionally inconsistent with the standard equation.
Common Pitfalls:
- Mixing units and constants from rail formulas or from m/s forms without proper conversion.
Final Answer:
e + f = V^2 / (225 R).