Series-opposing sources — when two voltage sources are series-opposing, should their voltages be added arithmetically to get the total? Evaluate this statement.
-
ACorrect
-
BIncorrect
-
CCorrect only if both sources are identical
-
DCorrect only for AC sources
Answer
Correct Answer: Incorrect
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Multiple sources in series combine according to their polarities. “Series-aiding” means voltages add; “series-opposing” means they subtract. This question checks whether you recognize that opposing sources reduce the net voltage instead of increasing it by addition.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Two ideal voltage sources in series.
- Opposing polarity orientation (one source fights the other).
- Linear, lumped circuit model.
Concept / Approach:The correct way to combine series sources is to take their algebraic sum with sign, not a blind arithmetic sum. If V1 and V2 are oriented so that one is a rise while the other is a drop in the same loop traversal, the net is V_net = V1 − V2 (magnitude per polarity). Only when the sources aid each other do they add: V_net = V1 + V2. Therefore, the statement “series-opposing sources are added” is wrong.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Assign loop direction and source polarities.Write KVL including algebraic signs for rises/drops.For opposing orientation: V_net = |V1 − V2| (with sign by chosen direction).Conclude: They do not add; they subtract.Verification / Alternative check:Example: 12 V source opposing a 9 V source → net 3 V. A DMM across the pair confirms ~3 V with polarity set by the larger source orientation, matching algebraic summation, not addition.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- Correct: Contradicts basic source combination rules.
- Only if identical / Only for AC: Irrelevant; algebraic sum applies regardless of equality or AC/DC as long as phasor polarities are considered for AC.
Common Pitfalls:Ignoring polarity arrows and simply summing magnitudes. Always mark polarities and signs before applying KVL.
Final Answer:Incorrect — series-opposing sources subtract; use the algebraic sum with signs.