Series RC driven by a sine source: initially XC = R so VR = VC. If the frequency is increased, how do the resistor and capacitor voltages compare?
-
AVR > VC
-
BVC > VR
-
CVR = VC
-
DVR and VC = 0
-
Erelationship cannot be determined
Answer
Correct Answer: VR > VC
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Voltage division in AC circuits depends on impedances, not just resistances. In a series RC, the capacitor’s reactance varies with frequency, changing the voltage distribution. This concept underlies filters, phase shifters, and sensor conditioning.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- A series RC circuit driven by a sine wave.
- At the starting frequency, XC = R, so VR = VC.
- Frequency is then increased; R and C values are unchanged.
Concept / Approach:Capacitive reactance is XC = 1 / (2 * π * f * C). As frequency f increases, XC decreases. In a series network, the magnitude of voltage across a component is proportional to its impedance magnitude. Therefore, with higher f, the capacitor’s impedance shrinks and takes a smaller share of the source voltage, while the resistor takes a larger share.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Start: XC = R ⇒ |VR| = |VC|.Increase frequency: XC decreases (inverse to f).Voltage division shifts so |VR| > |VC|.Verification / Alternative check:Numerical example with Vs = 1 V, R = 1 kΩ, C chosen so XC = 1 kΩ at f0. At 2f0, XC halves to 500 Ω. Voltage division yields VR ≈ 0.894 V, VC ≈ 0.447 V, confirming VR > VC.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- VC > VR: Opposite of frequency effect on XC.
- VR = VC: Only true when XC = R.
- VR and VC = 0: Not in a driven sinusoidal circuit.
Common Pitfalls:
- Treating XC as constant with frequency.
- Ignoring that phase angles change but here only magnitudes are compared.
Final Answer:VR > VC