Water in the urea reactor — During conversion of ammonium carbamate to urea, what is the effect of a large excess of water in the reacting solution?
-
AIt increases the yield of urea by shifting equilibrium to the right
-
BIt adversely affects (reduces) the yield of urea
-
CIt reduces the evaporator load by convenient dilution, with no yield penalty
-
DIt does not affect the yield of urea at all
-
EIt suppresses corrosion and therefore increases conversion
Answer
Correct Answer: It adversely affects (reduces) the yield of urea
Explanation
Introduction:The urea synthesis liquid contains NH3, CO2, ammonium carbamate, water, and urea. Water plays a dual role: it is a product of dehydration and a solvent. However, too much water negatively affects the equilibrium conversion to urea.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Liquid-phase reversible dehydration: NH2COONH4 ⇌ NH2CONH2 + H2O.
- High pressure, moderate temperature; downstream stripping/evaporation present.
- Activity effects: higher water concentration shifts equilibrium.
Concept / Approach:Le Châtelier’s principle applies: since water is a product, adding excess water drives the equilibrium back toward ammonium carbamate, lowering urea yield at a given temperature and pressure. Moreover, excess water increases the duty of downstream concentrators and can slow kinetics by dilution. Plants therefore control water balance and use high NH3/CO2 ratios and stripping to enhance conversion.
Step-by-Step Solution:Consider equilibrium: adding product (water) shifts left.Assess process impact: more water → lower conversion, higher evaporation duty.Conclude that large excess water adversely affects yield.
Verification / Alternative check:Simulation and plant data show conversion drops with higher water content at fixed T, P, and NH3/CO2, validating the adverse effect.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- Increasing yield would require removal of water/volatile components, not addition.
- “No yield penalty” ignores equilibrium and kinetic dilution effects.
- Corrosion mitigation is separate and does not inherently raise conversion.
Common Pitfalls:Assuming dilution always helps reactions; overlooking that water is a reaction product here.
Final Answer:It adversely affects (reduces) the yield of urea