Sarda fall discharge formula: For a trapezoidal crest operating under free over-fall, which discharge expression is appropriate (symbols: L crest length, H head over crest, B canal bed width, g gravity)?
-
A0.45 * sqrt(2g) * L * H^(3/2) * (H/B)^(1/3)
-
B0.45 * sqrt(2g) * L * H^(2/3) * (H/B)^(2/3)
-
C0.45 * sqrt(2g) * L * H^(3/2) * (H/B)^(1/6)
-
D0.45 * sqrt(2g) * L * H^(1/6) * (H/B)^(3/2)
-
E0.45 * sqrt(2g) * L * H^(5/3) * (B/H)^(1/6)
Answer
Correct Answer: 0.45 * sqrt(2g) * L * H^(3/2) * (H/B)^(1/6)
Explanation
Introduction / Context:
Sarda type falls are canal falls designed to measure and dissipate energy while passing discharge. The empirical rating for their crests (rectangular or trapezoidal) modifies the standard sharp-crested weir relation Q ∝ L * H^(3/2) with a width-ratio correction to account for approach conditions.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Free over-fall (modular flow) with negligible submergence.
- Trapezoidal crest used on distributaries as per standard layouts.
- Correction term involves the relative head H to bed width B.
Concept / Approach:
The base weir equation Q = C * L * H^(3/2) is adapted with C ≈ 0.45 * sqrt(2g) for Sarda fall geometry and an additional factor (H/B)^(1/6) that captures approach contraction effects. Thus the formula becomes Q = 0.45 * sqrt(2g) * L * H^(3/2) * (H/B)^(1/6).
Step-by-Step Solution:
Start with weir-type discharge: Q ∝ L * H^(3/2).Apply Sarda empirical coefficient: C ≈ 0.45 * sqrt(2g).Include approach correction: multiply by (H/B)^(1/6).Select the matching option → the expression with H^(3/2) and exponent 1/6 on H/B.Verification / Alternative check:
Comparisons with standard rating tables for Sarda falls confirm the 1/6 exponent trend for trapezoidal crests under free fall conditions.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- Different exponents on H or (H/B) distort the empirical calibration.
- Expressions with H^(2/3), H^(1/6), or inverted ratios do not match established Sarda ratings.
Common Pitfalls:
- Using the rectangular crest coefficient for trapezoidal crests without correction.
- Applying the formula under submergence without submergence corrections.
Final Answer:
0.45 * sqrt(2g) * L * H^(3/2) * (H/B)^(1/6)