Difficulty: Easy
Correct Answer: If the customer is not satisfied and their needs are not met, the project cannot be considered fully successful, even if internal processes were followed.
Explanation:
Introduction / Context:
One of the core ideas in modern project management is that success is not measured solely by adherence to internal processes, budgets, and schedules. Customer satisfaction and the degree to which the project meets stakeholder needs and expectations are critical dimensions of overall success. PMI based frameworks emphasize that a project delivered on time and on budget can still fail if it does not satisfy the customer or meet the intended business objectives.
Given Data / Assumptions:
Concept / Approach:
Project success is multi dimensional, including meeting scope, time, and cost baselines as well as fulfilling quality standards and satisfying key stakeholders. When the customer, who is a major stakeholder, is clearly dissatisfied and believes their needs were not met, the project cannot be regarded as fully successful, even if internal project management practices were followed. PMI emphasizes that stakeholder satisfaction and benefits realization are important outcomes. Thus, a negative customer reaction signals that something important has failed, whether in requirements gathering, scope definition, communication, or solution design.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Step 1: Recognize that the customer is explicitly stating their needs were not fulfilled.
Step 2: Recall that meeting stakeholder needs and expectations, especially the customer's, is a major component of project success.
Step 3: Understand that adherence to methodology alone is not enough if the delivered product or service does not satisfy the customer.
Step 4: Review the answer options and choose the one that directly links customer dissatisfaction to the conclusion that the project is not successful.
Step 5: Select option B, which accurately states that without customer satisfaction, the project cannot be considered fully successful.
Verification / Alternative check:
PMI's discussions of success criteria often mention both internal performance (time, cost, scope, quality) and external measures such as customer satisfaction and business value. Real world case studies frequently show that projects delivered to technical specifications but misaligned with stakeholder needs are called failures. This reinforces that the customer's perspective is critical and supports the conclusion in option B.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
Option A trivializes the customer's dissatisfaction and ignores its impact on success. Option C focuses solely on change control and wrongly suggests that documentation issues alone are the problem. Option D blames the customer's communication and implies that their dissatisfaction does not matter, which is not acceptable in professional project management. Option E asserts that time and budget alone define success, contradicting PMI's broader view that stakeholder satisfaction and benefits realization are essential components of success.
Common Pitfalls:
A common pitfall is equating successful project management with successful business outcomes. It is possible to manage a project well from an internal perspective but still deliver something the customer does not value. Another mistake is to discount customer feedback because it arrives late in the project; in reality, that feedback should be treated seriously and used as a lesson learned for improving requirements management and stakeholder engagement on future projects.
Final Answer:
The most accurate conclusion is that if the customer is not satisfied and their needs are not met, the project cannot be considered fully successful, even if internal processes were followed.
Discussion & Comments