Coagulants in sewage treatment: Which of the following is generally not used as a coagulant for treating sewage (wastewater)?
-
AAlum (aluminium sulfate)
-
BFerric chloride
-
CFerric sulfate
-
DChlorinated copperas
-
EPolyaluminium chloride (PAC)
Answer
Correct Answer: Chlorinated copperas
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Chemical coagulation is sometimes applied to wastewater for enhanced primary treatment or tertiary polishing. Knowing which coagulants are typical for sewage, as opposed to potable water, helps in selecting cost-effective chemicals and avoiding side effects.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Sewage characteristics: higher organics, variable pH/alkalinity compared with raw surface water.
- Goal: identify coagulants conventionally adopted for sewage.
Concept / Approach:In wastewater, ferric salts (ferric chloride/sulfate) and alum are commonly used for chemical phosphorus removal, suspended solids reduction, and enhanced clarification. “Chlorinated copperas” (chlorinated ferrous sulfate) has niche or historical use, more associated with water treatment/odor control contexts, and is generally not a standard coagulant for sewage treatment trains.
Step-by-Step Solution:List typical sewage coagulants: alum, ferric chloride, ferric sulfate, PAC.Assess chlorinated copperas: not commonly deployed for municipal sewage coagulation.Select the exception.
Verification / Alternative check:Practice guidelines and plant case studies widely report ferric and alum chemistry for sewage; chlorinated copperas seldom appears as a standard choice for coagulation in municipal wastewater.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:Alum, ferric chloride/sulfate, and PAC are widely used in wastewater for solids and phosphorus removal.
Common Pitfalls:
- Assuming chemicals popular in water treatment are equally prevalent in wastewater.
- Ignoring impacts on alkalinity and sludge production when choosing coagulants.
Final Answer:Chlorinated copperas