In municipal sanitation terminology, identify the incorrect statement about sewage and sewerage systems.
-
AThe mixture of water and waste products is called sewage
-
BTreated sewage effluents are commonly reused for crop irrigation
-
CThe processes of collecting, conveying, treating, and disposing of sewage are collectively called sewerage
-
DThe old conservancy system was definitely better than the water-carried sewerage system
-
ENone of these
Answer
Correct Answer: The old conservancy system was definitely better than the water-carried sewerage system
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Accurate use of sanitation terminology is foundational for design, regulation, and public communication. This question checks understanding of basic definitions and system comparisons.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Sewage includes domestic, commercial, and in some cases industrial wastewater with varying dilution.
- Effluent reuse for irrigation is practiced under guidelines.
- Conservancy systems historically relied on manual collection rather than water-carriage.
Concept / Approach:The water-carried sewerage system is globally preferred over the conservancy system due to hygiene, labor safety, odor control, and scalability. Definitions of sewage and sewerage are standardized across engineering literature.
Step-by-Step Solution:Check (a): correct—sewage is wastewater plus carried waste products.Check (b): correct—treated effluent irrigation is practiced where standards permit.Check (c): correct—sewerage encompasses the full system and processes.Check (d): incorrect—conservancy is outdated and inferior on public-health grounds.
Verification / Alternative check:Modern codes mandate water-carried sewerage or on-site systems meeting strict criteria; conservancy is maintained only in exceptional legacy contexts.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- (a), (b), and (c) are standard definitions and practices.
- (e) is wrong because (d) is demonstrably incorrect.
Common Pitfalls:Confusing the terms sewage (the wastewater) and sewerage (the system). Also assuming all effluents are reusable without treatment—standards must be met first.
Final Answer:The old conservancy system was definitely better than the water-carried sewerage system.