For a watershed with fair pasture cover, if potential infiltration s = 10 cm and storm rainfall P = 12 cm, what is the direct runoff depth Q?
-
A2 cm
-
B3 cm
-
C5 cm
-
D8 cm
Answer
Correct Answer: 2 cm
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Quick event-based runoff estimates often use simple abstractions where a potential infiltration depth s is subtracted from rainfall depth P to compute direct runoff Q. This is useful for rapid checks and teaching fundamentals before applying full SCS-CN or infiltration-capacity models.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Potential infiltration s = 10 cm.
- Storm rainfall P = 12 cm.
- Neglect other abstractions (interception, depression storage) for this simplified calculation.
Concept / Approach:If rainfall does not exceed potential infiltration, no direct runoff occurs. If it exceeds s, the excess becomes runoff. Hence: Q = max(0, P − s). This linear model captures the threshold behavior simply and is commonly introduced in hydrology courses.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Compute excess rainfall: P − s = 12 − 10 = 2 cm.Since 12 > 10, runoff exists and equals the excess.Therefore, Q = 2 cm.Verification / Alternative check:While SCS-CN could give a slightly different value depending on Ia and S, the question clearly frames the simple potential-infiltration model, so the linear result stands.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- 3 cm, 5 cm, 8 cm: Do not match P − s = 2 cm for the specified s and P under this model.
Common Pitfalls:
- Accidentally using P/s or other ratios instead of the threshold subtraction.
- Forgetting that runoff cannot be negative.
Final Answer:2 cm