Rolled sections for railway bridges: Which of the following dimensions corresponds to a standard plate girder section used in bridge work?
-
A851 mm × 254 mm
-
B255 mm × 254 mm
-
C551 mm × 254 mm
-
D851 mm × 851 mm
-
E851 mm × 125 mm
Answer
Correct Answer: 851 mm × 254 mm
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Bridge superstructures in railways often use plate girders or built-up/rolled sections. Recognizing common dimensional designations helps in selecting members for webs and flanges. This question asks which dimensional pair corresponds to a typical large girder depth (≈ 851 mm) with a flange width around 254 mm seen in common catalogues/past specifications.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Dimensions are listed as overall depth × flange width.
- We select the plausible combination used in bridge practice.
Concept / Approach:Among the given sizes, 851 × 254 mm aligns with known heavy rolled/built-up girder proportions, where depth is roughly 3–4× the flange width for bending efficiency. Other listed pairs are either square or too small in depth for main girders.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Review options for realistic girder proportions.Identify 851 × 254 mm as a practical deep-girder proportion used historically.Select 851 mm × 254 mm.Verification / Alternative check:Typical steel catalogues and railway design examples exhibit deep plates/rolled units where depth is about 700–1000 mm with flanges around 200–300 mm; 851 × 254 mm fits that envelope.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- 255 × 254 mm and 551 × 254 mm: Too shallow for many bridge main girders.
- 851 × 851 mm: Impractical square proportion for a plate girder.
- 851 × 125 mm: Flange too narrow for the quoted depth.
Common Pitfalls:
- Confusing rolled universal beams with built-up plate girders; dimensions should remain realistic for bending needs.
Final Answer:851 mm × 254 mm