Hydrology—Unit hydrograph theory: Compared to the peak discharge of a 4-hour unit hydrograph for the same basin, the peak discharge of the instantaneous unit hydrograph (IUH) will be:
-
Agreater
-
Bequal
-
Cequal or lesser
-
Dlesser
-
Eindeterminate without rainfall depth
Answer
Correct Answer: greater
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Unit hydrographs describe a basin’s direct runoff response to a unit depth of effective rainfall over a specified duration. As the rainfall duration shortens, runoff is concentrated in time, making the hydrograph sharper and peakier. The theoretical limit is the instantaneous unit hydrograph (IUH).
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Same basin, linear system assumption.
- Comparison between a finite-duration (4-hour) unit hydrograph and IUH.
- Unit depth of effective rainfall in both cases.
Concept / Approach:
Reducing rainfall duration for the same unit depth compresses runoff timing and increases peak discharge while preserving total volume (area under hydrograph). Hence, IUH, as the zero-duration limit, has the most concentrated response and the highest peak.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Recognize: area under UH = unit runoff volume (constant).Shorter duration → narrower base for similar area → higher peak.Therefore, IUH peak > 4-hour UH peak.Verification / Alternative check:
Constructing UHs of varying duration from an IUH via convolution shows peaks decrease as duration increases, confirming the relationship.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- Equal or lesser contradicts the concentration principle; equal is only a degenerate case.
Common Pitfalls:
- Confusing peak discharge with total volume (which stays constant for a unit depth).
Final Answer:
greater