In IS 456 design for reinforced concrete beams, the span-to-depth ratio limits are specified primarily to ensure which serviceability criterion is respected?
-
Atensile crack width is below a limit
-
Bshear failure is avoided
-
Cstress in the tension reinforcement is less than the allowable value
-
Ddeflection of the beam is below a limiting value
-
Etorsional rigidity is maximized
Answer
Correct Answer: deflection of the beam is below a limiting value
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Serviceability governs how a structure performs in use—particularly deflections and crack widths. IS 456 specifies span/depth (L/d) limits for beams to control excessive long-term and short-term deflections without detailed calculations, ensuring occupant comfort, finish integrity, and line-of-sight performance in floors and roofs.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Reinforced concrete beam spans and depths are design variables.
- Code provides L/d limits with modification factors for tension steel percentage and compression reinforcement.
- We are asked for the primary reason for these limits.
Concept / Approach:
The code’s basic L/d limits act as a prescriptive deflection control. While crack width has separate detailing provisions, and shear failure is addressed by shear design, the span/depth limits directly address the risk of excessive deflection under service loads, including creep and shrinkage effects.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Identify the serviceability concern directly controlled by L/d → deflection.Note that crack control uses bar spacing and cover rules, not L/d directly.Hence, select the deflection option.Verification / Alternative check:
IS 456 tables list basic L/d values (e.g., 20 for simply supported beams, etc.) modified for reinforcement percentages, confirming a deflection-control intent.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- Crack width is managed via bar diameter/spacing and tensile stress limits.
- Shear failure is prevented by shear design (Vc + Vs), not by L/d limits.
- Allowable stresses relate to limit state checks, not prescriptive L/d limits.
Common Pitfalls:
- Ignoring long-term deflection from creep and shrinkage when near the limit.
Final Answer:
deflection of the beam is below a limiting value