In the long-and-short-wall method of estimation, the length of a long wall is taken as the centre-to-centre distance between walls plus which allowance?
-
AOne full breadth of wall (added once).
-
BHalf breadth of the wall on each side (i.e., add 0.5B at both ends).
-
COne-fourth breadth of the wall on each side.
-
DNo allowance; use only centre-to-centre distance.
-
EDeduct half breadth on each side.
Answer
Correct Answer: Half breadth of the wall on each side (i.e., add 0.5B at both ends).
Explanation
Introduction / Context:The long-and-short-wall method is a classic approach to estimate quantities of masonry. It distinguishes between external (long) and internal (short) walls and prescribes how to compute their lengths for volume or area calculations.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Long walls are measured out-to-out; short walls in-to-in.
- Centre-to-centre spacing and wall thickness B are known.
- We seek the correct allowance for long-wall length.
Concept / Approach:For long walls, out-to-out length = centre-to-centre length + half breadth at each end (total +B). For short walls, in-to-in length = centre-to-centre length − half breadth at each end (total −B). This ensures joints and overlaps are correctly accounted when summing item quantities.
Step-by-Step Solution:Long wall out-to-out = L_c/c + 0.5B (left) + 0.5B (right) = L_c/c + B.Therefore the rule is “add half breadth on each side”.Select option that states this explicitly.
Verification / Alternative check:Worked examples in estimation textbooks consistently apply +B for long walls and −B for short walls when moving from centre lines.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- A overstates the rule (adds full breadth at one end only).
- C is an arbitrary fraction not used.
- D ignores necessary out-to-out allowance.
- E reverses the correct adjustment.
Common Pitfalls:Applying the same sign for both long and short walls; forgetting to adjust at junctions and for openings.
Final Answer:Half breadth of the wall on each side (i.e., add 0.5B at both ends).