Difficulty: Medium
Correct Answer: Only II and III follow
Explanation:
Introduction / Context:Course-of-action questions test whether proposed steps are proportionate, feasible, and directly relevant to the stated problem. Here, repeated near-miss events point to systemic stress in terminal airspace capacity and human-systems performance (pilots, ATC, procedures). Logical actions should reduce congestion risk and strengthen human factors, training, and procedures while respecting due process.
Given Data / Assumptions:
Concept / Approach:Prefer actions that (a) immediately lower traffic density and complexity, and (b) improve ATC competence and coordination. Avoid punitive measures without investigation. Systems safety focuses on de-risking the operating context and enhancing training and procedures rather than scapegoating individuals absent facts.
Step-by-Step Solution:
1) Course I (de-roster all six pilots): Summary punishment without inquiry is not logically warranted by the statement. Pilots actually prevented collisions; causation points more toward airspace/ATC load, not proven pilot error.2) Course II (divert flights): Decongestion reduces simultaneous conflicts, controller workload, and separation errors; this is targeted and proportionate.3) Course III (ATC refresher in batches): Directly strengthens conflict detection, communication discipline, and contingency handling without shutting operations.4) Therefore, Only II and III logically follow.Verification / Alternative check:Common safety improvements after repeated level busts/TCAS RAs include traffic flow management (slotting, diversions), updated procedures, and recurrent training for ATC and flight crews.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
• Only I / I with others: Premature and misdirected; lacks due process and may remove the very pilots who demonstrated crisis handling.• Only II or Only III: Each helps; together they better address both load and human factors.• None of these: Ignores clear, proportionate remedies.Common Pitfalls:Assuming punitive action equals safety; ignoring airspace capacity management.
Final Answer:Only II and III follow.
Discussion & Comments