18 men can complete a piece of work in 63 days. 9 women take 189 days to complete the same piece of work. How many days will 4 men, 9 women and 12 children together take to complete the piece of work if 7 children alone can complete the piece of work in 486 days? (I.R.M.A., 2007)
Aptitude
Time and Work
Difficulty: Hard
Choose an option
-
A54
-
B63
-
C76
-
D81
-
ENone of these
Answer
Correct Answer: 81
Explanation
### Concept & Total Work (LCM Method)
For complex multi-group problems, defining a large arbitrary "Total Work" unit by finding the Least Common Multiple (LCM) of the total man-days for each group prevents messy fractional math.
$$ \text{Total Work (Units)} = \text{LCM}(W_M, W_W, W_C) $$
### Step-by-Step Solution
* **Calculate Total Worker-Days for Each Group:**
Men: $18 \text{ men} \times 63 \text{ days} = 1134 \text{ man-days}$.
Women: $9 \text{ women} \times 189 \text{ days} = 1701 \text{ woman-days}$.
Children: $7 \text{ children} \times 486 \text{ days} = 3402 \text{ child-days}$.
* **Establish Total Work & Efficiencies:** Let's find the LCM of $1134$, $1701$, and $3402$.
Notice that $1134 \times 3 = 3402$ and $1701 \times 2 = 3402$.
So, Total Work = $3402 \text{ units}$.
Efficiency of $1 \text{ man (M)} = 3402 / 1134 = 3 \text{ units/day}$.
Efficiency of $1 \text{ woman (W)} = 3402 / 1701 = 2 \text{ units/day}$.
Efficiency of $1 \text{ child (C)} = 3402 / 3402 = 1 \text{ unit/day}$.
* **Calculate Target Group Efficiency:**
Target group: $4 \text{ men} + 9 \text{ women} + 12 \text{ children}$.
Combined efficiency = $4(3) + 9(2) + 12(1)$
Combined efficiency = $12 + 18 + 12 = 42 \text{ units/day}$.
* **Calculate Total Time:**
Time taken = Total Work / Combined Efficiency
Time = $3402 / 42$
Time = $81 \text{ days}$.
### Exam Strategy & Shortcut
Instead of full LCM, use the ratio of total worker-days to find relative strengths.
Work $= 1134M = 1701W = 3402C$.
Divide by the largest number ($3402$): $1C = \frac{1}{2}W = \frac{1}{3}M$. This tells us $1M = 3C$ and $1W = 1.5C$ (wait, let's use integers for easier math).
Multiply by $6$: $6C = 3W = 2M$.
Target: $4M + 9W + 12C$. Convert all to $C$:
$4M = 12C$.
$9W = 18C$.
Total target $= 12C + 18C + 12C = 42C$.
We know $7C$ take $486$ days. So $1C$ takes $7 \times 486 = 3402$ days.
Therefore, $42C$ will take $3402 / 42 = 81$ days.
### Common Pitfall
The primary source of error here is arithmetic mistakes due to the large numbers involved in calculating the total man-days ($18 \times 63$, $7 \times 486$, etc.). Carefully checking these initial products is critical.
### Final Answer
Therefore, the correct answer is **81**.