If 12 men and 16 boys can do a piece of work in 5 days; 13 men and 24 boys can do it in 4 days, then the ratio of the daily work done by a man to that of a boy is
Aptitude
Time and Work
Difficulty: Medium
Choose an option
-
A2 : 1
-
B3 : 1
-
C3 : 2
-
D5 : 4
Answer
Correct Answer: 2 : 1
Explanation
### Concept & Equating Total Work
When two different groups complete the same piece of work in different numbers of days, the total work (Workforce $\times$ Days) for both groups is equal. Equating these allows us to find the efficiency relationship between the individual worker types.
$$M_1 \times D_1 = M_2 \times D_2$$
### Step-by-Step Solution
* **Define variables:** Let the daily work of a man be $m$ and a boy be $b$.
* **Calculate total work from the first group:** 12 men and 16 boys finish the work in 5 days.
* Total Work = $5 \times (12m + 16b)$.
* **Calculate total work from the second group:** 13 men and 24 boys finish the work in 4 days.
* Total Work = $4 \times (13m + 24b)$.
* **Equate and solve:** Since both groups are doing the same work, set the equations equal to each other.
* $5(12m + 16b) = 4(13m + 24b)$.
* $60m + 80b = 52m + 96b$.
* Move $m$ terms to one side and $b$ terms to the other.
* $60m - 52m = 96b - 80b$.
* $8m = 16b$.
* Simplify by dividing by 8.
* $1m = 2b$.
* **Determine ratio:** The ratio of a man's daily work to a boy's is $m/b = 2/1$.
### Exam Strategy & Shortcut
Quickly cross-multiply the days and the workforce numbers mentally: $(12 \times 5)m = 60m$ vs $(13 \times 4)m = 52m$, difference is $8m$. For boys: $(16 \times 5)b = 80b$ vs $(24 \times 4)b = 96b$, difference is $16b$. Thus, $8m = 16b \Rightarrow m = 2b$. The ratio is $2:1$.
### Common Pitfall
Miscalculating the distribution when multiplying the days across the workforce numbers (e.g., forgetting to multiply the boys by the days).
### Final Answer
Therefore, the correct answer is **2 : 1**.