In the Whitworth quick-return motion mechanism (an inversion of the slider–crank), the kinematic composition consists of three turning (revolute) pairs and one sliding pair—state whether this statement is correct for the standard crank-and-slotted-lever form.
-
ARight
-
BWrong
-
COnly true for special geometries
-
DTrue only at one extreme position
-
EIndeterminate from the data
Answer
Correct Answer: Right
Explanation
Introduction / Context
The Whitworth quick-return mechanism achieves unequal cutting and return times by converting uniform crank rotation into non-uniform lever oscillation. Recognizing its joint types helps in DOF (degree of freedom) accounting, wear analysis, and synthesis.
Given Data / Assumptions
- Standard crank-and-slotted-lever Whitworth mechanism.
- Ideal pin joints (revolute) and a block sliding in a slot.
- Planar kinematics.
Concept / Approach
The Whitworth mechanism is an inversion of the slider–crank chain in which a slotted lever oscillates about a fixed pivot. A crank drives a block (slider) that moves inside the slot. The joints are: (i) crank to frame (turning pair), (ii) crank pin to block (turning pair), (iii) block in slot (sliding pair), and (iv) lever to frame (turning pair). Hence 3 revolute + 1 prismatic (sliding).
Step-by-Step Solution
1) Enumerate links: frame, crank, block (slider), slotted lever.2) Enumerate joints: crank–frame (R), crank–block (R), block–slot (P), lever–frame (R).3) Count: 3 turning (revolute) pairs and 1 sliding pair.Verification / Alternative check
Gruebler’s criterion with one DOF confirms consistent mobility for a four-link, four-joint (three R, one P) planar mechanism.
Why Other Options Are Wrong
- Wrong: contradicts the standard geometry and joint inventory.
- Only true for special geometries: joint types do not change with geometry; only proportions change the quick-return ratio.
- True only at one extreme position: joint classification is not configuration-dependent.
- Indeterminate: the classic form is well-defined.
Common Pitfalls
- Confusing the Whitworth with the slotted-disk or drag-link quick-return variants; the joint count here is specific to the crank-and-slotted-lever mechanism.
Final Answer
Right