For a two-cylinder locomotive (cranks at right angles) with fraction c of reciprocating mass balanced on each side, which expression correctly represents the periodic tractive force along the line of stroke in terms of m, ω, r, and crank angle θ?
-
Am·ω²·r cos θ
-
Bc·m·ω²·r sin θ
-
C(1 - c)m·ω²·r (cos θ - sin θ)
-
Dm·ω²·r (cos θ - sin θ)
-
E(1 + c)m·ω²·r (cos θ + sin θ)
Answer
Correct Answer: (1 - c)m·ω²·r (cos θ - sin θ)
Explanation
Introduction / Context
The net tractive (longitudinal) force in a locomotive varies cyclically due to the inertia of reciprocating parts in each cylinder. Partial balancing introduces rotating counterweights equal to a fraction c of the reciprocating mass, modifying the amplitude of the horizontal resultant.
Given Data / Assumptions
- Two identical cylinders with cranks at 90° (right angle).
- Reciprocating mass per side: m; balanced fraction: c.
- Crank radius r; crank speed ω; crank angle θ for one side.
Concept / Approach
The unbalanced horizontal inertia force for one cylinder varies as m·ω²·r cosθ. With cranks at 90°, the other contributes m·ω²·r sinθ (phase-shifted). Partial balancing removes fraction c of each component (via rotating counterweights), leaving (1 − c) times the original components. The net tractive-force fluctuation is proportional to their algebraic combination along the line of stroke.
Step-by-Step Solution
1) Side A (along stroke): FA = (1 − c)m·ω²·r cosθ.2) Side B (quadrature): component along the same line is FB = −(1 − c)m·ω²·r sinθ (sign from orthogonal projection and phase).3) Net along the line: F = FA + FB = (1 − c)m·ω²·r (cosθ − sinθ).Verification / Alternative check
Setting c = 0 (no balancing) gives F = m·ω²·r (cosθ − sinθ), matching the unbalanced case; increasing c reduces the amplitude linearly, confirming the (1 − c) factor.
Why Other Options Are Wrong
- m·ω²·r cos θ: ignores the second cylinder and balancing.
- c·m·ω²·r sin θ: uses c instead of (1 − c) and omits the cosθ term.
- m·ω²·r (cos θ − sin θ): correct shape but corresponds to c = 0 (no balancing).
- (1 + c)m·ω²·r (cos θ + sin θ): incorrect sign and amplitude; does not model partial balancing.
Common Pitfalls
- Forgetting the 90° phase shift between the two cranks.
- Applying the balancing fraction with the wrong sign or to the wrong components.
Final Answer
(1 - c)m·ω²·r (cos θ - sin θ)