C#.NET — Allocation of struct variables and reference fields. Given: class Trial { int i; decimal d; } struct Sample { private int x; private float y; private Trial z; // reference-type field } Sample ss = new Sample(); Which statement is correct?

Difficulty: Easy

Correct Answer: ss will be created on the stack.

Explanation:


Introduction / Context:
This item examines how value-type variables (struct instances) and reference-type fields within them are allocated. It is crucial to distinguish between the struct variable itself and any object that a reference field might point to.


Given Data / Assumptions:

  • Sample is a struct (value type) containing an int, a float, and a reference field z of type Trial.
  • Statement shown: Sample ss = new Sample(); (assume a local variable in a method).


Concept / Approach:
A struct variable declared as a local typically lives in the stack frame. The reference field z is just a reference (like a pointer) stored within the struct; unless initialized with new Trial(), it remains null and points to no object. Any Trial instance would be a reference type and lives on the heap when created. The important distinction: creating the struct does not automatically create an instance of Trial.


Step-by-Step Solution:

Evaluate ss: as a local struct variable, its storage is inline in the stack frame → stack. Evaluate z: at this point, z is a null reference; no Trial object has been created. If later code did “ss.z = new Trial();” then that Trial object would be allocated on the heap as a reference type. Therefore, among the given choices, the correct statement is that ss is created on the stack.


Verification / Alternative check:
Using ss within another class field changes storage: if a struct is a field within a heap object, the struct data lives inside that heap object. The type category (value vs reference) still remains unchanged.


Why Other Options Are Wrong:

  • A/D: Treat ss as a heap allocation, which is not the case for a local value-type variable.
  • B: Reference-type instances (Trial) are never created on the stack by “new”.
  • C: z is a reference field inside the struct; it is not “created on the heap” by itself; it would point to a heap object only after explicit instantiation.


Common Pitfalls:
Assuming that fields of a struct are separately heap-allocated or that creating a struct automatically creates referenced objects.


Final Answer:
ss will be created on the stack.

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion