Refrigerant selection — identify the undesirable property For a refrigerant used in vapor-compression systems, which of the following is an undesirable thermophysical or safety property for practical HVAC/R applications?
-
Ahigh boiling point
-
Bnon-explosive
-
Cnon-flammable
-
Dnon-toxic
-
Echemically stable
Answer
Correct Answer: high boiling point
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Refrigerant choice affects efficiency, component size, environmental impact, and safety. Key properties include normal boiling point, flammability, toxicity, chemical stability, and compatibility with materials.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Comparing single properties in isolation for typical HVAC/R equipment.
- Focus on practical desirability in compressors, condensers, and evaporators.
Concept / Approach:A desirable refrigerant should boil at a low temperature at near-atmospheric pressure to achieve evaporating temperatures below ambient while keeping suction pressures moderate. Safety attributes (non-toxic, non-flammable, non-explosive) and chemical stability are also desirable. Therefore, a high boiling point is undesirable because it forces high evaporator pressures and limits low-temperature operation.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Recall: low normal boiling point → effective cooling at moderate pressures.High boiling point → poor low-temperature capability or excessive pressure ratios.Hence, among the listed properties, “high boiling point” is undesirable.Verification / Alternative check:Examine pressure-temperature charts: refrigerants with low boiling points achieve sub-zero evaporator temperatures without extreme suction pressures; high-boiling fluids would require impractical conditions.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
Non-toxic, non-flammable, non-explosive, and chemically stable are all desirable safety and reliability attributes.
Common Pitfalls:Confusing normal boiling point with critical temperature; both matter, but the normal boiling point directly relates to evaporator operating ranges.
Final Answer:
high boiling point