Stefan–Boltzmann law and mode of heat transfer Is the Stefan–Boltzmann law applicable to convection heat transfer, or only to thermal radiation?
-
AAgree
-
BDisagree
-
CApplicable to conduction only
-
DApplicable to mass transfer only
-
ENot a heat-transfer law
Answer
Correct Answer: Disagree
Explanation
Introduction / Context:This item checks whether you can correctly associate classic heat-transfer laws with the proper mode: conduction, convection, or radiation. The Stefan–Boltzmann law is often misapplied outside radiation.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- No participating media (clear line-of-sight radiation, gray/diffuse surface approximations acceptable).
- Convection is a surface–fluid phenomenon depending on fluid motion and properties.
Concept / Approach:The Stefan–Boltzmann law states that the total hemispherical emissive power of an ideal blackbody is E_b = σ * T^4. Net radiative exchange between real surfaces uses this as a basis with emissivity and view factors. Convection uses Newton’s law of cooling, q_conv = h * A * (T_s − T_∞), not T^4.
Step-by-Step Solution:Identify the mode: Stefan–Boltzmann involves radiation.Write the form: q_rad = ε * σ * A * (T_s^4 − T_sur^4).Convection depends on film coefficient h, not σ, so the law does not apply to convection.
Verification / Alternative check:Compare units: σ has units W/m^2·K^4, while h has units W/m^2·K. Different physics, different laws.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- Agree: incorrect—σT^4 is radiative, not convective.
- Conduction only / mass transfer only / not a heat-transfer law: all incorrect descriptions.
Common Pitfalls:Confusing high-temperature convection with radiation; forgetting that radiation scales with the fourth power of absolute temperature.
Final Answer:Disagree