Why is a triangular (V-notch) weir preferred over a rectangular notch? In open-channel flow measurement, select the most appropriate reason set explaining why a triangular V-notch is often chosen instead of a rectangular notch, especially for small discharges.

Difficulty: Easy

Correct Answer: all the above

Explanation:


Introduction / Context:
Weirs are standard devices for measuring open-channel discharge. Among common shapes, the triangular (V-notch) weir is widely preferred for laboratory, irrigation, and drainage applications where flows are relatively small and accuracy at low heads is important.



Given Data / Assumptions:

  • Sharp-crested notch/weir under free, fully aerated flow.
  • Head (h) measured above the notch crest at a standard upstream distance.
  • Coefficient of discharge approximately constant over typical operating heads for a V-notch of fixed angle (often 90°).


Concept / Approach:
For a sharp-crested triangular notch, the ideal discharge varies with h^(5/2): Q = (8/15) * C_d * √(2g) * tan(θ/2) * h^(5/2). The stronger head exponent (5/2) compared with the rectangular notch's 3/2 makes the V-notch more sensitive at low heads, improving practical accuracy. Only a single head measurement is needed, and one plate can cover a wide flow range by virtue of the notch geometry.



Step-by-Step Solution:

Recognize the application: accurate measurement at small discharges.Note that V-notch discharge Q ∝ h^(5/2), giving higher sensitivity.Operationally, only the head h is read; geometry is fixed.The same notch accommodates a wide flow range because rising head effectively opens a larger portion of the V.


Verification / Alternative check:
Compare percentage change in Q for a small change in h for V-notch vs rectangular notch; the higher exponent produces larger relative change, hence finer resolution.



Why Other Options Are Wrong:
Each partial statement is true; selecting only one omits other genuine advantages. The comprehensive correct choice is “all the above”.



Common Pitfalls:
Ignoring aeration (submergence reduces accuracy); reading head too close to the nappe; using the rectangular notch for very low flows where measurement resolution suffers.



Final Answer:
all the above

More Questions from Hydraulics

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion