If a train takes 1.75 sec to cross a telegraphic post and 1.5 sec to overtake a cyclist racing along a road parallel to the track @ 10 metres per second, then the length of the train is
Aptitude
Problems on Trains
Difficulty: Hard
Choose an option
-
A105 m
-
B115 m
-
C125 m
-
D135 m
Answer
Correct Answer: 105 m
Explanation
### Concept & Relative Speed Anomaly
Usually, "overtake" implies moving in the same direction. However, if the time taken to cross a moving object (1.5s) is *less* than the time taken to cross a stationary object (1.75s), the relative speed must be higher than the train's speed. This means the cyclist is actually moving in the *opposite* direction, despite the word "overtake".
$$Length = Speed \times Time$$
### Step-by-Step Solution
1. Let the length of the train be $L$ meters and its speed be $v$ m/s.
2. **Stationary Post:**
- Time = 1.75 s.
- $L = v \times 1.75 \implies L = 1.75v$
3. **Cyclist:**
- Cyclist speed = 10 m/s. Time = 1.5 s.
- Because 1.5s < 1.75s, relative speed must be $v + 10$ (opposite direction).
- $L = (v + 10) \times 1.5 \implies L = 1.5v + 15$
4. **Equate and Solve:**
- $1.75v = 1.5v + 15$
- $0.25v = 15$
- $v = \frac{15}{0.25} = 60$ m/s
5. **Find Length:**
- $L = 1.75 \times 60 = 105$ meters.
### Exam Strategy & Shortcut
Set up a quick ratio. $L/1.75 = v$ and $L/1.5 = v + 10$. Subtracting them gives $L(1/1.5 - 1/1.75) = 10$. $L(\frac{1.75 - 1.5}{1.5 \times 1.75}) = 10 \implies L(\frac{0.25}{2.625}) = 10 \implies L = 105$ m.
### Common Pitfall
Taking "overtake" strictly as same-direction and formulating the equation $L = (v - 10) \times 1.5$. This results in a negative speed and impossible geometry. You must infer the physical reality from the time variables given.
### Final Answer
Therefore, the correct answer is **105 m**.