What is the speed of a train if it overtakes two persons who are walking in the same direction at the rate of $a$ m/s and $(a + 1)$ m/s and passes them completely in $b$ seconds and $(b + 1)$ seconds respectively? (C.D.S., 2004)
Aptitude
Problems on Trains
Difficulty: Medium
Choose an option
-
A$(a + b)$ m/s
-
B$(a + b + 1)$ m/s
-
C$(2a + 1)$ m/s
-
D$\frac{(2a + 1)}{2}$ m/s
Answer
Correct Answer: $(a + b + 1)$ m/s
Explanation
### Concept & Algebraic Formulation
When a train overtakes objects moving in the same direction, the distance covered equals the train's length, and the effective speed is the difference between their speeds.
$$ L = (V - u) \times t $$
### Step-by-Step Solution
* Let the speed of the train be $v$ m/s and its length be $L$ meters.
* The train passes the first person moving at $a$ m/s in $b$ seconds. So, $L = (v - a) \times b$.
* The train passes the second person moving at $(a + 1)$ m/s in $(b + 1)$ seconds. So, $L = (v - (a + 1)) \times (b + 1)$.
* Equating the lengths: $(v - a)b = (v - a - 1)(b + 1)$.
* Expanding both sides: $vb - ab = vb + v - ab - a - b - 1$.
* Canceling common terms ($vb$ and $-ab$): $0 = v - a - b - 1$.
* Solving for $v$: $v = a + b + 1$.
### Exam Strategy & Shortcut
For a general pattern where speeds increase by 1 unit and times increase by 1 unit, the train's speed is always the sum of the initial speed, initial time, and the increment.
### Common Pitfall
Making algebraic sign errors when expanding the terms $(v - (a + 1))(b + 1)$. Always use brackets carefully.
### Final Answer
Therefore, the correct answer is **$(a + b + 1)$ m/s**.