Three containers $A$, $B$ and $C$ are having mixtures of milk and water in the ratio $1 : 5$, $3 : 5$ and $5 : 7$ respectively. If the capacities of the containers are in the ratio $5 : 4 : 5$, find the ratio of milk to water, if the mixtures of all the three containers are mixed together?
Aptitude
Alligation or Mixture
Difficulty: Hard
Choose an option
-
A$51 : 115$
-
B$52 : 115$
-
C$53 : 115$
-
D$54 : 115$
Answer
Correct Answer: $53 : 115$
Explanation
### Concept & Mixtures with Unequal Capacities
When mixing containers with different capacities and internal ratios, combine the LCM method for equalizing the ratio sums with a multiplier that reflects the capacity ratio of the containers.
### Step-by-Step Solution
* **Given:**
- Container A ratio = $1 : 5$ (Sum = $6$)
- Container B ratio = $3 : 5$ (Sum = $8$)
- Container C ratio = $5 : 7$ (Sum = $12$)
- Ratio of capacities A:B:C = $5 : 4 : 5$
* **Calculation:**
1. Find the LCM of the ratio sums ($6, 8, 12$), which is $24$.
2. To account for the capacities, multiply the LCM by the capacity ratio for each container:
- Capacity of A = $24 \times 5 = 120$ units
- Capacity of B = $24 \times 4 = 96$ units
- Capacity of C = $24 \times 5 = 120$ units
3. Calculate the amount of milk and water in each container:
- Container A: Milk = $\frac{1}{6} \times 120 = 20$; Water = $120 - 20 = 100$
- Container B: Milk = $\frac{3}{8} \times 96 = 36$; Water = $96 - 36 = 60$
- Container C: Milk = $\frac{5}{12} \times 120 = 50$; Water = $120 - 50 = 70$
4. Total Milk = $20 + 36 + 50 = 106$ units
5. Total Water = $100 + 60 + 70 = 230$ units
6. The final ratio of milk to water is $106 : 230$.
7. Simplifying the ratio by dividing by $2$ yields $53 : 115$.
### Exam Strategy & Shortcut
Equalize the base denominators first ($6, 8, 12 \rightarrow$ scale to $24$).
A's fraction scaled: $4:20$.
B's fraction scaled: $9:15$.
C's fraction scaled: $10:14$.
Now multiply each by their respective capacity weights ($5, 4, 5$).
A: $(4 \times 5) : (20 \times 5) = 20 : 100$
B: $(9 \times 4) : (15 \times 4) = 36 : 60$
C: $(10 \times 5) : (14 \times 5) = 50 : 70$
Summing them gives $106 : 230 = 53 : 115$.
### Common Pitfall
A frequent error is forgetting to apply the capacity weights ($5:4:5$) after finding the common base for the internal fractions, treating them as if they were of equal volume.
### Final Answer
Therefore, the correct answer is **$53 : 115$**.