Thermometer applicability at sub-zero conditions: Which thermometer type cannot reliably measure sub-zero temperatures (below 0°C) in standard practice without special modifications?

Difficulty: Easy

Correct Answer: Mercury-in-glass thermometer

Explanation:


Introduction / Context:
Selecting a thermometer for cold-region or cryogenic-adjacent service hinges on whether the sensing medium remains liquid and responsive below 0°C. Many industrial and laboratory questions stress that simple mercury-in-glass instruments are not suitable for routine sub-zero measurements, whereas alcohol or gas systems are commonly preferred.


Given Data / Assumptions:

  • “Standard practice” implies typical, unmodified instruments.
  • Sub-zero means temperatures below 0°C.
  • Mechanical integrity and readability are part of suitability, not merely theoretical range.


Concept / Approach:
Mercury freezes at around −39°C, and even above that, mercury-in-glass thermometers require special design (e.g., nitrogen-filled) for reliable sub-zero operation. In practical exam contexts, the accepted guidance is that mercury-in-glass is unsuitable for sub-zero work; alcohol-in-glass, vapour-pressure, gas-filled, or RTD devices are used instead because their working medium performs better below 0°C and the readout can be remote or electrical as needed.


Step-by-Step Solution:

Identify the limiting factor: mercury’s behaviour below 0°C.Contrast with alternatives: alcohols and gas systems remain useful well below 0°C; RTDs are electrical and cover wide ranges.Conclude the standard choice that “cannot measure sub-zero” in this context is mercury-in-glass.


Verification / Alternative check:
Instrument handbooks prescribe alcohol-filled or gas-filled devices for low temperatures and caution about mercury separation and readability issues below 0°C unless specially constructed.


Why Other Options Are Wrong:

Bimetallic — workable below 0°C; metal strip deformation continues at low temperatures.Vapour-pressure — designed for remote indication across low ranges.RTD — excellent low-temperature performance with proper wiring.Gas-filled bulb — suited to low-temperature measurement.


Common Pitfalls:
Assuming any mercury thermometer works fine below freezing; in practice, specialised designs are needed, hence the general rule used in exams.


Final Answer:
Mercury-in-glass thermometer

More Questions from Process Control and Instrumentation

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion