Why are synchronous modems typically more expensive than asynchronous modems in data communication systems?

Difficulty: Easy

Correct Answer: They contain clock recovery circuits

Explanation:


Introduction / Context:
Synchronous and asynchronous modems differ in how they align sender and receiver timing. Cost differences arise from the additional circuitry and signal processing needed to maintain bit/byte alignment without start/stop overhead.


Given Data / Assumptions:

  • Synchronous links send a continuous bit stream without per-character start/stop bits.
  • Receivers must align to the sender's bit timing accurately.
  • Asynchronous links embed timing via start/stop bits, reducing timing complexity.


Concept / Approach:

In synchronous transmission, timing is recovered from the incoming signal using a clock recovery circuit (e.g., PLL). This hardware (and sometimes DSP logic) adds complexity and cost. Asynchronous modems avoid this by delimiting characters with start/stop bits at known intervals.


Step-by-Step Solution:

Identify what synchronous transmission lacks: per-character timing markers.Determine what is required instead: robust clock recovery to lock receiver timing to the transmitter.Link to cost: additional analog/digital circuitry and tighter tolerances increase price.Select the option that names the key added component: clock recovery circuits.


Verification / Alternative check:

Standards for synchronous links (e.g., HDLC/PPP framing at the data link layer) assume continuous streams with external or embedded clocking, reinforcing the need for clock extraction hardware.


Why Other Options Are Wrong:

Large volume of data: Volume is an outcome, not the reason for higher cost.

Start/stop bits: That is asynchronous behavior, not synchronous.

Larger bandwidth: Not inherently required; synchronous vs asynchronous is about timing, not necessarily bandwidth.

None of the above: Incorrect because clock recovery is the reason.


Common Pitfalls:

Assuming synchronous always implies higher data rate; cost stems from timing circuitry, not merely speed.


Final Answer:

They contain clock recovery circuits

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion