A sum of ₹ 731 is divided among A, B and C such that A receives 25% more than B and B receives 25% less than C. What is C's share in the amount? (Bank P.O., 2006)
Aptitude
Ratio and Proportion
Difficulty: Medium
Choose an option
-
A₹ 172
-
B₹ 200
-
C₹ 258
-
D₹ 262
-
ENone of these
Answer
Correct Answer: None of these
Explanation
### Concept & Chained Ratios
When shares are linked by percentages, it is easiest to set the final person in the chain to a base value (like 100 or a variable $x$) and work backward to express all shares in terms of that base.
$$ \text{Final Share} = \frac{\text{Individual Ratio}}{\text{Sum of Ratios}} \times \text{Total Amount} $$
### Step-by-Step Solution
1. **Define variables working backward:**
Let C's share be $x$.
2. **Express B's share:**
B receives 25% less than C.
$B = x - 0.25x = 0.75x = \frac{3}{4}x$
3. **Express A's share:**
A receives 25% more than B.
$A = B + 0.25B = 1.25B = \frac{5}{4}B$
Substitute B's value: $A = \frac{5}{4} \times \left(\frac{3}{4}x\right) = \frac{15}{16}x$
4. **Find the combined ratio A : B : C:**
$A : B : C = \frac{15}{16}x : \frac{3}{4}x : x$
To clear the denominators, multiply the entire ratio by 16:
$A : B : C = 15 : 12 : 16$
5. **Calculate C's share:**
Total ratio parts = $15 + 12 + 16 = 43$.
Total amount = ₹ 731.
$C = \frac{16}{43} \times 731$
$C = 16 \times 17 = 272$
### Exam Strategy & Shortcut
Instead of fractions, use numbers! Let C = 160 (a number easily divisible by 4 twice).
B is 25% less: $160 - 40 = 120$.
A is 25% more than B: $120 + 30 = 150$.
Ratio is $150 : 120 : 160 = 15 : 12 : 16$.
Sum = $43 \implies 43 \text{ units} = 731 \implies 1 \text{ unit} = 17$.
C's share = $16 \text{ units} = 16 \times 17 = 272$.
### Common Pitfall
A frequent error is calculating "25% more" or "25% less" based on the same base amount. Percentages are strictly relative to their immediate reference points (B is relative to C, A is relative to B).
### Final Answer
Therefore, the correct answer is **None of these**.