English Grammar – Spot the error (choose the erroneous segment or ‘‘No error’’). Sentence: We never thought that Mahesh is oldest than the other players in the team.

Difficulty: Easy

Correct Answer: oldest than the other

Explanation:


Introduction / Context:
This checks comparative vs. superlative forms with “than”. Use the comparative (“older than”), not the superlative (“oldest”), when directly comparing two sets via “than”.



Given Data / Assumptions:

  • Comparison marker: “than”.
  • Target adjective: old → older/oldest.
  • Group contrasted: Mahesh vs. the other players.


Concept / Approach:
Rule: Use the comparative + “than” for two-way comparisons (“older than others”). Use the superlative + “of/in” when singling out one from a group (“the oldest of the team”). Therefore, “oldest than” is ungrammatical. Also, sequence-of-tense often prefers “was” after “thought,” but that is secondary to the clear comparative error.



Step-by-Step Solution:

Replace “oldest” with “older”.Optional tense backshift for reported thought: “was”.Correct sentence: “We never thought that Mahesh was older than the other players in the team.”


Verification / Alternative check:
Superlative route: “the oldest of all the players in the team” (acceptable), but then remove “than”. This confirms why “oldest than” is wrong.



Why Other Options Are Wrong/Acceptable:

  • A and D are fine.
  • B could be “was” for backshift, but “is” can stand in timeless commentary; still, C contains the definite error.
  • E cannot be chosen.


Common Pitfalls:
Mixing superlatives with “than”; forgetting that “other” is needed when comparing a member with the rest of its group.



Final Answer:
oldest than the other

More Questions from Spotting Errors

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion