Paraffin displacement (clod method): A soil clod is oven-dry, then coated with paraffin and weighed. Total weight (soil + paraffin) = 460 g. When immersed, it displaces 299 cm^3 of water. Paraffin weighs 10 g and has specific gravity 0.9. If Gs (solids) = 2.5, compute the void ratio e of the soil.
Correct Answer: 0.60
Introduction / Context:The paraffin (clod) method measures the bulk volume of an irregular soil clod by displacement after coating with a thin paraffin film. Knowing the dry mass and particle specific gravity allows determination of the volume of solids and thus the void ratio e = Vv / Vs. This problem exemplifies careful accounting for the paraffin shell volume.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Total mass (soil + paraffin) = 460 g; paraffin mass = 10 g.
- Displaced water volume (coated clod) = 299 cm^3.
- Specific gravity: paraffin = 0.9; soil solids Gs = 2.5; water density 1 g/cm^3.
- Soil clod is oven-dry (mass of soil solids = 460 − 10 = 450 g).
Concept / Approach:
External volume from displacement includes soil + paraffin. Subtract the paraffin volume to get the bulk soil volume. Then compute Vs from dry mass and Gs. The void volume is Vv = V − Vs, and e = Vv / Vs.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Paraffin volume V_p = mass / density = 10 / 0.9 = 11.111 cm^3.Bulk soil volume V = displaced − V_p = 299 − 11.111 = 287.889 cm^3.Volume of solids Vs = Ms / (Gs * ρ_w) = 450 / (2.5 * 1) = 180.000 cm^3.Void volume Vv = V − Vs = 287.889 − 180.000 = 107.889 cm^3.Void ratio e = Vv / Vs = 107.889 / 180.000 ≈ 0.599 ≈ 0.60.Verification / Alternative check:
Dimensional consistency: volumes in cm^3 and masses in g with water at 1 g/cm^3 yield a dimensionless e. The value e ≈ 0.60 is typical for a medium-dense sandy silt/sand mixture, providing a reasonableness check.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
0.55, 0.65, 0.70 deviate from the precise computation; 0.48 is too low given the volumes.
Common Pitfalls:
Forgetting to subtract the paraffin volume; using wet mass instead of dry mass for Vs; mixing units; rounding too early.
Final Answer:
0.60