Sensitivity of clays (St): ratio of undisturbed to remoulded undrained strength Sensitivity St is defined as St = cu(undisturbed) / cu(remoulded) at the same water content. What value best represents a “quick clay” from the given choices?
-
A4
-
B8
-
C12
-
D16
-
E20
Answer
Correct Answer: 20
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Sensitivity quantifies the loss of undrained shear strength when clay is remoulded at constant water content. High sensitivities indicate severe structure/ bonding that collapses upon disturbance. “Quick clays” are famous for dramatic strength loss leading to flow slides.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- St = cu(undisturbed) / cu(remoulded) at same w.
- Typical classification (indicative): low < 4, medium 4–8, high 8–16, very high 16–32, quick >≈ 30 (many references).
- Choices provided are discrete numbers.
Concept / Approach:
Quick clays exhibit very high to extremely high sensitivity, often > 16 and typically > 30. Among the given options, 20 lies in the “very high” range and is the best representative of a quick-clay behavior compared with smaller offered values.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Identify the classification ranges from common practice.Map offered choices to the closest applicable range.Select 20 as most consistent with quick-clay characteristics among given options.Verification / Alternative check:
Well-documented Nordic quick clays often show St > 30, but when constrained to the listed numbers, 20 best captures the “very high/quick” behavior as opposed to 4–16 which are lower categories.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
4, 8, 12, 16 correspond to low–high sensitivity, insufficient to typify quick clays. 20 is closer to the expected extreme sensitivity.
Common Pitfalls:
Assuming a single universal threshold; ignoring mineralogy and structure; not ensuring water content equality when measuring St.
Final Answer:
20